Jimmy Carter: The Unfinished
Presidency
Penguin Books, 1999
"With
its astonishing detail and subtle insights, it
is hard to imagine that this definitive account
will ever be surpassed." -
Peter G. Bourne, Author of Jimmy
Carter: A Comprehensive Biography from Plains
to Postpresidency.
 
"Jimmy Carter is the most
active and influential former president since Teddy Roosevelt. He has earned
everyone’s admiration and become a model
of how to not just carry on but to contribute after leaving the White House.
Douglas Brinkley, the best of the new generation of American historians, tells
us in vigorous language the story of Carter’s quite amazing range of
activities, at home and around the world. As a bonus, The Unfinished Presidency
offers a marvelous portraits of a wide range of world leaders, as seen from
the unique perspective of Jimmy Carter. Highly recommended!" –
Stephen E. Ambrose, Author of Undaunted Courage
"Douglas Brinkley, one of our most exciting historians,
not only provides a richly textured narrative of Carter’s amazing postpresidency,
he also uses the story to explore the relationship between realism and moral
values in American foreign policy." – Walter Isaacson,
Author of Kissinger
"This superb book shows how broad, sustained, and controversial
were Carter’s efforts in Panama, Nicaragua, Haiti, the Middle East, the
Gulf War, and Korea. Every chapter is filled with insight and revelation." – Gaddis
Smith, Learned Professor of History, Yale University
"With fastidious research and extraordinary access
to his subject, Brinkley has brought us a fascinating, thoughtful account
of Jimmy Carter after the White House – easily the most detailed real-time
inside look we have ever had at an American ex-president." – Michael
Beschloss,
Author of Taking Charge: The Johnson White House Tapes, 1963-64
"Jimmy Carter has given the role of ex-president new
luster; and Douglas Brinkley’s excellent book records the possibilities
and perils of an activist ex-presidency with candor, insight, and readability.
A fine history!" – Arthur Schlesinger Jr.
Out of Retirement
Related Link: First Chapter: 'The Unfinished Presidency' |
By GODFREY HODGSON
Former President Jimmy Carter has tried to mediate some of the world's most
stubborn conflicts.
Only a decade ago, more than
five million people, mostly in central Africa, were afflicted by a disgusting
parasite called the Guinea worm. It lives inside the human body for a year
before breaking the skin as a two-to-three-foot-long worm. Agonizingly painful,
it can cause sepsis and even tetanus, which is often fatal.
Jimmy Carter had never heard of Guinea worm disease until his friend Dr.
Peter Bourne gave a presentation about it. His response was characteristic.
''If Guinea worm is so easy to eradicate,'' he asked, ''why is it not being
done?'' Within months he had persuaded the World Health Organization to make
it the No. 2 priority after smallpox. He toured Africa, talking Guinea worm
with the dodgy Pakistani banker Agha Hasan Abedi (of B.C.C.I. fame), and
talked Du Pont into supplying millions of drinking-water filters and American
Cyanamid into providing larvicides. Into the bargain, he called in his markers
from a dozen African and Asian leaders, urging them to campaign for the disease's
eradication. The number of cases in the world is now under 100,000.
After his humiliating re-election defeat in 1980, Carter retired to Plains,
Ga., where his family has been prominent for over 100 years. His staff presented
him with the best Sears, Roebuck could do in woodworking tools. Before long
he was making furniture and gifts like cedar-lined cigar boxes. He loves
fly-fishing too, writes competent poetry and still regularly teaches Sunday
school at the interracial Maranatha Baptist Church, which the Carters joined
because Plains Baptist, where they originally worshiped, voted to get rid
of a pastor who had welcomed black people to the congregation.
But Carter, an ex-President of the United States at 56, was not about to
contemplate graceful retirement. His religion is deeply held and passionate,
but it is of the covenanting, not the quietist, strain. Once he had recovered
from the hurt of his loss, and an entirely human, quite unsaintly resentment
of the way he had been misrepresented by the Republicans and the media, he
threw himself into one crusade after another, for human health, human rights
and above all for what he considers one of the most fundamental of those
rights: peace.
All ex-Presidents get to have a library to house their archives and scholars
who want to work on them. Carter decided to set up, alongside his library
in Atlanta, the Carter Center. His wife, Rosalynn, tells a Horatio Alger-style
story about how the idea for a center to carry on the ideals of the Camp
David accords he had brokered between Israel and Egypt came to him in the
middle of the night. The truth was more complex. But the central idea of
the Carter Center did derive from Camp David. He wanted to create a place
where the parties to the world's most stubborn conflicts could come together
and work out solutions.
Raising the money for the center, from the Coca-Cola Company and from most
of the largest foundations in America, consumed a great deal of Carter's
time. But he also found time to work with saw and hammer (and a great deal
of publicity) for the charity Habitat for Humanity, created by his good-ol'-Georgia-boy
friend Millard Fuller. He began a campaign to distribute drugs that can cure
''river blindness,'' which threatens 120 million people, again mainly in
Africa, with losing their sight.
Most important, he set himself up as a private-enterprise crusader for world
peace. Sometimes his efforts were done in harness with Washington or with
other world leaders, sometimes alone. Sometimes he supervised elections and
guaranteed their legitimacy, as in Panama and Nicaragua. Sometimes he inserted
himself into dangerous confrontations to head off conflict, as in Haiti and
North Korea. Most persistently and most controversially, he tried to repeat
his Camp David success by offering himself as a mediator in the Middle East,
and ended up so identified with the Palestinian cause that his efforts were
largely self-defeating.
Douglas Brinkley has told the story of Jimmy Carter's second and subsequent
comings with critical sympathy and a wealth of research. On occasion he seems,
like his subject, a little naive about the wicked world out there. Certainly
the reader is sometimes brought up with a start by the ethnocentric nature
of his take on the world. He calls Egypt's Copts ''Coptics,'' for example,
and his accounts of the conflict in the former Yugoslavia and his explanation
of Arab-Israeli history are seriously simplistic. For a historian (he is
director of the Eisenhower Center at the University of New Orleans and the
author of books on James Forrestal, Dean Acheson and Franklin D. Roosevelt),
Brinkley is curiously incurious about history; here is the Middle East without
Zionism or the Holocaust, and Yugoslavia without the Ottoman Empire or the
Nazi invasion.
He is excellent, however, at bringing to life the elusive personality, sweet
yet angular, of Jimmy Carter himself. He quotes a perceptive assessment by
David Brinkley (no relation), that ''despite his intelligence, he had a vindictive
streak, a mean streak, that surfaced frequently and antagonized people.''
Much of ''The Unfinished Presidency'' is a commentary on the two sides of
Carter's personality: his Christian values and his fierce, competitive egotism.
This dualism pervades his private life. Carter refuses to see visitors who
arrive even as little as one minute late, and made his wife miserable by
criticizing her if she was late in getting ready to go out. Then, one year,
he forgot to buy her a birthday present. So he sat down and wrote her a note,
promising not to make a fuss when she was late. ''He kept to his word,''
she joked, ''but he does tap his foot impatiently on occasion.''
Self-righteousness may be the worst temptation of the righteous, and many
of the flaws debited against Carter's impressive post-Presidential achievements
can be set down to that unattractive failing. At times, as after his successful
negotiation with the North Korean dictator Kim Il Sung, he came close to
spoiling the effect by going on CNN (which, thanks to Carter's trout-fishing
friendship with Ted Turner, often acted like his personal network) and upstaging
the White House.
Carter's relations with successive Presidents have been bad, sometimes in
ways that raised the question of whether he has continued to resent his 1980
defeat. His relations with Bill Clinton have been oddest of all. In a telling
passage, Brinkley points out that though they were both moderate Southern
governors, they ''had about as much in common as, well, a peanut farmer from
the Deep South and a Yale-and-Oxford-educated lawyer from Arkansas, a state
that is as much Western and Midwestern as it is Southern.'' He quotes William
Fulbright as saying, ''Carter had deep roots; Clinton had none.''
CARTER has acquired the reputation of being on the left. In domestic terms,
that is far from the case. But his foreign policy is deeply in rebellion
against many of the assumptions of the last five decades of orthodoxy. Although,
as befits a former naval officer, he is not against war in all circumstances,
he has opposed almost every exertion of American military force since Vietnam.
Compulsively, he sides with underdogs and outsiders. His religion commits
him to what Brinkley well calls this ''dialogue with the ostracized.'' But
it has led him to strange bedfellows. In the interests of mediation, he has
found it easy to forgive some fairly rank sinners, from Kim Il Sung to Manuel
Noriega. Strangest of all, for many, are his fondness for Yasir Arafat, who
flattered him shamelessly, and his undeniable bias, if not against Israel,
at least against Likud governments and politicians.
Even Carter's severest critics, though, will find it hard to be unmoved by
his blend of idealism and practicality. ''Conferences and committees are
not an end in themselves,'' he once wrote in righteous anger. ''I need something
a peanut farmer can (a) Understand and (b) Do.'' Like him or not, a reader
of this remarkable book may well conclude that this peanut farmer has understood
more than anyone imagined, and done more than anyone expected.
Godfrey Hodgson is the director of the Reuter Foundation Program for journalists
at Oxford University.
Kirkus Reviews
April 15, 1998
If you wonder why Jimmy Carter was so unsuccessful as a president
and outstanding as an ex-president, this book is for you.
Carter's reaction
to the Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI) captures the essence of the Carter
enigma. Promoting a technically impossible ''Star Wars'' scheme, Carter believed,
was dishonest. Yet as historian Brinkley (Univ. of New Orleans; Dean Acheson,
1992) points out, Carter's public condemnation of SDI reveals not only moral
conviction, but also an utter inability to consider that the Reagan administration
was simply using SDI to pressure the Soviets. As president, Carter was a man
of moral absolutes in a world colored in shades of gray. As an ex-president,
however, this same quality leaves him undeterred by concerns that prevent public
officials from moving forward. To gain peace Carter will sit down with terrorists;
tunnel vision can be instrumental when it is the ultimate goal that matters.
The moralistic Carter has ''turned the establishment of personal rapport with
political outlaws into a diplomatic art form,'' and the world is better off
as a result. Brinkley is a sympathetic biographer, but Carter's less admirable
traitsunrelenting competitiveness, an occasional mean streak, and the oft-noted
self-righteousnessare recognized along with the qualities Brinkley admires.
Be forewarned, however: Brinkley is also an encyclopedic biographer. This volume
reflects a decision to interrupt work on a complete biography of Carter to
write a ''short book'' on Carter's post-presidency. That this ''short book''
runs 500 pages reflects Brinkley's emphasis on comprehensiveness, resulting
in a sometimes tedious ''first he did this, then he did that'' tone that makes
the work less lively than it should be. But there are also delightful vignettes,
such as Brinkleys discussion of the origins of Habitat for Humanity, that make
persevering to the end worthwhile.
Carter's post-presidency appears not as an
''unfinished'' presidency, but rather as the continuation of work that was
always about more, for Carter, than being president.

USA TODAY
May 21, 1998
In terms of sheer scope, Jimmy Carter's post-presidential
projects open a window on the level of self-confidence, industry, energy, tenacity
and goal-setting ability it takes to become president
in the first place.
This exhaustive history of Carter's years as a former U.S.
president takes readers from November 1980 and Carter's raw grief over his
eviction from the White House at the hands of Ronald Reagan to
January 1998 and an Oval Office meeting in which a scandal-seized President
Clinton asked for his prayers.
Historian Douglas Brinkley of the University of New Orleans
portrays the 38th U.S. president as a brilliant, studious and untiring humanist.
Running through this lengthy work is a discussion of how
Carter's Christian faith holds him duty-bound to use his personal
gifts to build shelter for the homeless, feed the hungry, clothe the naked,
care for the sick and promote peace.
The Unfinished Presidency is an unauthorized biography, not
a hostile one. It's clear that Brinkley spent months with Carter and his wife,
Rosalynn, debriefing them about their reflections and motivations.
Rosalynn Carter recalls a night in
January 1982 when the "grand notion" for The Carter Center came
to her husband. She thought he was sick when he suddenly sat up in bed. He
told her he'd figured
out what to do with his presidential library, saying: ''We're going to make
it a place to resolve conflicts. No place like that exists."
Brinkley's work provides as much insight to the work of The
Carter Center as to the very public life Carter has led, and recorded in his
own prolific writings, since 1980.
Brinkley discusses how Carter's friendship with fellow Georgian
and CNN founder Ted Turner helped keep his foreign views before the public.
Turner sent a camera crew to follow Carter as he trotted the globe.
Brinkley recounts how Carter parlayed his personal contacts
and expertise in advisory roles in the foreign policy operations that Reagan,
Clinton and George Bush pursued in the Middle East. And he details how Carter
played public relations consultant to PLO leader Yassir Arafat, tutoring him
on how to tailor pronouncements for U.S. consumption.
From what began as exile in Plains, Brinkley analyzes how
Carter raised the practice of thinking globally and acting locally to high
diplomatic art. The historian sums up a key criticism of Carter this way: "He's
all offense and no defense, like a star basketball forward who scores 40 points
while his team loses.
But Brinkley does not buy it. His book stacks up evidence
of Carter's tangible successes.
He estimates, for instance, that while Carter is no longer
leader of the free world, he has coupled his personal power of persuasion with
the power of the presidency to win the release of approximately 50,000 prisoners
of conscience since he left office.
He gives Carter credit for mediating peace efforts between
warring factions in Ethiopia and Eritrea, Sudan, Nicaragua, Haiti, North Korea
and Bosnia. And tells how Carter became an international media hero by monitoring
elections in Central America and Africa.
Brinkley's book also illuminates a little-known area of Carter's
good works. Carter has pursued the eradication of infectious diseases and hunger
around the world by enlisting prize-winning epidemiologists and agronomists.
Brinkley presents illustrations of Carter as husband, farmer,
military strategist, Sunday school teacher and neighbor in a relaxed, conversational
style. Until Carter authorizes a biography, this rigorously footnoted text
gives a thoroughly sourced intimate portrait of one of the country's most respected
ex-presidents.
 
Coming soon.

|